Table of Contents

EU Cosmetic Allergen Regulation 2023

The European Union has long been at the forefront of consumer protection, particularly in the realm of cosmetics and personal care products. In a significant move to enhance transparency and safety, the EU has introduced Regulation 2023/1545, which expands the list of fragrance allergens that must be declared on cosmetic product labels. This article provides an in-depth look at the new regulation, its implications for the cosmetics industry, and the steps companies need to take to ensure compliance.

Background and Key Changes

The journey towards more comprehensive allergen labeling began in 2012 when the Scientific Committee on Consumer Safety (SCCS) issued an opinion recommending that consumers be informed about additional fragrance ingredients in cosmetic products. This recommendation was based on growing evidence of the allergenic potential of certain fragrance compounds.

On July 27, 2023, the European Union officially published Regulation 2023/1545 in the Official Journal of the European Union (OJEU). This regulation amends the existing Cosmetic Products Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009, introducing several key changes:

  1. Expanded Allergen List: The regulation adds 56 new fragrance ingredients to Annex III of the EU Cosmetic Products Regulation. These substances must now be indicated on the label if their presence exceeds certain thresholds.
  2. Concentration Thresholds:
    • For leave-on products: 0.001%
    • For rinse-off products: 0.01%
  3. Implementation Timeline:
    • July 31, 2026: Deadline for selling or withdrawing non-compliant products already on the market.
    • July 31, 2028: Deadline for placing new products compliant with the updated provisions on the EU market.

The new allergens list includes substances such as 3-Propylidenephthalide, Acetyl Cedrene, Alpha-Terpinene, Amyl Salicylate, Anethole, Benzaldehyde, various Citrus oils, Eucalyptus Globulus Oil, Jasmine Oil/Extract, Lavandula Oil/Extract, Menthol, Rose Flower Oil / Extract, Santalum Album Oil, and Vanillin, among others. (Note: This is a partial list. The full list of 56 substances can be found in the original regulation text.)

Implications for the Cosmetics Industry

  1. Formulation Reviews: Companies will need to conduct comprehensive reviews of their product formulations to identify the presence and concentration of these new allergens.
  2. Label Updates: Significant changes to product labels will be necessary to include the new allergens when present above the specified thresholds.
  3. Supply Chain Transparency: Manufacturers will need to work closely with their fragrance suppliers to obtain detailed information on the composition of fragrances used in their products.
  4. Safety Assessments: Updated safety assessments may be required for products containing the newly listed allergens.
  5. Consumer Education: Companies may need to engage in consumer education initiatives to explain the new labeling and its importance.

Steps for Compliance

To ensure compliance with EU Regulation 2023/1545, cosmetic companies should consider the following steps:

  1. Ingredient Review: Conduct a thorough review of all fragrances used in your products. Utilize testing laboratories to identify allergens present and determine if their concentrations fall under the labeling requirements.
  2. Safety Testing: Perform necessary safety tests, which may include:
    • Human Repeat Insult Patch Test (HRIPT)
    • Phototoxicity and Photoallergy Testing
    • Analytical Testing
    • Comprehensive Risk Assessment
  3. Label Updates: Revise product labels to include the names of any fragrance allergens that meet or exceed the concentration thresholds. Ensure that the labeling is clear, legible, and easily accessible to consumers.
  4. Staff Training: Educate all relevant staff members about the new regulation and its implications for product development, manufacturing, and quality control.
  5. Supply Chain Communication: Engage with fragrance suppliers to ensure they can provide detailed information on the composition of fragrances and that they comply with the new regulation.
  6. Documentation: Maintain thorough documentation of all steps taken to comply with the regulation, including ingredient analyses, safety assessments, and label updates.

Global Impact and Future Considerations

While EU Regulation 2023/1545 directly applies to the European Union market, its impact is likely to be felt globally. Many countries look to EU cosmetics regulations as a benchmark for their own regulatory frameworks. As of September 2023, approximately 50 countries were either directly referencing EU regulatory restrictions on ingredients in their local cosmetic regulations or continuously adapting their requirements to mirror EU standards.

Companies operating in the global market should consider adopting these new labeling requirements across their product lines to ensure consistency and to stay ahead of potential regulatory changes in other regions.

Additional Insights

  1. Reformulation Opportunities: This regulation may drive innovation in fragrance formulation, encouraging the development of hypoallergenic alternatives or novel scent combinations that minimize the use of known allergens.
  2. Natural vs. Synthetic Debate: The inclusion of many natural extracts and essential oils in the allergen list may reignite discussions about the safety of natural vs. synthetic fragrances in cosmetics.
  3. Analytical Challenges: The low concentration thresholds, particularly for leave-on products (0.001%), may present analytical challenges for some manufacturers. Investment in advanced analytical techniques and equipment might be necessary.
  4. Consumer Awareness: As more allergens are labeled, there may be an increase in consumer awareness and demand for fragrance-free or hypoallergenic products, potentially shifting market trends.
  5. Digital Solutions: To manage the complexity of formulation and labeling requirements, companies may increasingly turn to digital solutions and software for ingredient management and regulatory compliance.

Conclusion

EU Regulation 2023/1545 represents a significant step towards greater consumer protection and transparency in the cosmetics and personal care sector. While compliance may present challenges, it also offers an opportunity for companies to demonstrate their commitment to consumer safety and build trust with their customers.

As the deadlines approach, it is crucial for cosmetic manufacturers to start preparing now. By taking proactive steps to understand and implement these new requirements, companies can ensure they are well-positioned to maintain consumer trust and market access within the EU and potentially in other markets that may follow suit.

The cosmetics industry has always been at the forefront of innovation, and this regulation presents another opportunity for companies to innovate in their approach to product formulation, labeling, and consumer communication. Those who embrace these changes and invest in thorough safety testing and transparent labeling will likely find themselves at a competitive advantage in an increasingly safety-conscious market.

Publications related to

Long valued for its benefits, talc faces scrutiny over asbestos contamination risks. Explore the ongoing debate, high-profile cases, and potential impacts of a European talc ban on the cosmetics industry.
This is the story of how CRC Team went beyond traditional sourcing to help a renowned Australian skincare group successfully navigate the complex landscape of sustainable packaging in China, paving the way for their ethical and eco-friendly market entry.
How Knudsen&CRC Team engineered a seamless market entry, balancing strict regulatory compliance with core brand values of sustainability and wellness.
Launching a new brand is always a challenge. Now, imagine doing it in one of the world’s most complex regulatory environments while staying true to your ethical principles. This is the story of how CRC Team went beyond compliance to help Bulldog Skincare.